Midweek Rumble: Redshirt VS Storm Trooper

TheWizard

This week, it's those characters who you know are gonna die anyway... but before that happens, they meet in an alley.

If a Redshirt threw down with a Storm Trooper, who would stand victorious and why?

(here's the poll on Twitter)(thanks to Exile @Finjinimo for the fight) 

Drakythe

Storm Trooper

Storm Trooper.

I'm a fan of the theory that the Storm Troopers as portrayed in Episode IV are intentionally missing so that the crew can escape. They then proceed to kick ass in Empire Strikes Back and are only outmaneuvered in VI because the plot required it and care bears are awesome.

Redshirts for most of Star Trek are not truly combat trained individuals. So yeah, I'll take the combat military training of a ST over the exploratory/scientific/engineering training of a RS.

SecretOwl

Storm Trooper

Relevant and why I agree with @Drakythehttp://imgur.com/gallery/w5MHii8

SecretOwl

Storm Trooper

UNLESS: We are talking about Next Gen, then the ones wearing red shirts are officers

Psycho_Mycho

Redshirt

REDSHIRT!!! The storm trooper would just miss all his attempts to land a hit, whether it's with a gun or his fist. The redshirt would somehow accidentally trigger a building collapse, which would somehow kill the stormtrooper mere seconds before the redshirt dies too.

Psycho_Mycho

Redshirt

Drakythe said:

Storm Trooper.

I'm a fan of the theory that the Storm Troopers as portrayed in Episode IV are intentionally missing so that the crew can escape. They then proceed to kick ass in Empire Strikes Back and are only outmaneuvered in VI because the plot required it and care bears are awesome.

Redshirts for most of Star Trek are not truly combat trained individuals. So yeah, I'll take the combat military training of a ST over the exploratory/scientific/engineering training of a RS.

I like that theory! 

Nezuja

Redshirt

Redshirt wins by sacrafice! The redshirt would somehow get the ST in an inescapable life or death situation and they would both perish.

helpicantfly

Storm Trooper

redshirt is a sacrifice member so therefore would just kill themselves  

TheWizard

this one was good, nice work @Finjinimo. Wizard likey... (but he still disapproves of you, sir...)

Varking

Redshirt

Tied up at 4-4